Monday, August 2, 2010

To be or not to be.

The French author François de la Rochefoucauld wrote, "We are so accustomed to disguise ourselves to others that in the end we become disguised to ourselves."

This is the guy who came up with 500 reflections on human behaviour. You'd think more people would listen to what he had to say, and take him seriously!
As someone who is 17, not a kiddie, not really an adult, no one knows better what it means to live such a schizophrenic life. 
With your friends you're one person, with your parents another, with your sister you turn into a crazy monkey and at a book-club meeting the sober intellectual with spectacles falling off your nose.

So, what does it mean to be yourself? To be consistent in your behaviour and body language?
I don't see it that way, but most do.

To me, being yourself is being consistent in your basic ideologies and thought processes at all times. 

For example, do you believe in the necessity of violence? No, you say? If that's your answer in any given situation, you're being yourself. On the other hand, if you decide to tell your parents, "No, no, I hate war. Violence only provides temporary relief from hopelessness, and can never be a permanent answer," and tell your friends "War, from time to time refreshes the tree of liberty with the blood of tyrants and of patriots. War gives otherwise broken down old men something important to reminisce on. War is good."
.... That is being a little spineless and hypocritical in my books. 
What are your real opinions? (Do you even have any? :P)

I don't see how your behaviour with every single person in your life has much to do with "being yourself". 
You relate to every single person in a different manner, don't you? You can't possibly treat every single person in your life as cattle trains. Laugh at every joke every person in your life cracks, scream at one as mindlessly as you can at the other. They're all different, they all deserve a relatively unique place in your life. 
So, it's okay to be one person with your friend, and another with your parents.

That's what I believe to be correct. Theoretically, at least, it sounds okay to me.

The question is.
Does that not make you a little schizophrenic in the end? A little confused about who you really are? A tiny bit disillusioned with people, expectations, morality?

When and how do we come to terms with who we really are at the core?

Nietzsche wrote, "The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe."


11 comments:

Sandeep Kodam said...

When you rest your identity in the hands of others...one,without knowing this and the other,knowing this...taking action in one,and not in another.That makes 2*2=4 possibilities...so,I guess it's inevitable.Sorry,babe to freak you out like this!!!

sanket kambli said...

i dont think it is schizophrenic,,,its more like we wear a mask to deal with people/situations differently...

but when we think we have lost our self is when we dont have a mask for ourselves....

so its simple...people say be yourself..i think its non-sense...be something that people dont hate...

not ppl will no agree that and say what about ur identity...

but then isnt our habit of "being ourself" is also a way of pleasing/telling people..that see this me.accept me anyway...

so its quite confusing in the end...

so simple...mantra..live life..enjoy it... and dont get lost trying to find meaning..and lose the moment..

forgive me..if i was confusing.. i explain things better in person than in this small comments window..

Sandeep Kodam said...

I see that your consciousness of age has brought much complacency in your originality of thought.
It's interesting that you've picked Nietzsche...awesome guy,great philosophy but,careful,also weird(check out his opinions about women!!!).I'd be happy if you don't give a damn to what I say...
lovely post btw...
Even if I say or refrain from it,you'll always be yourself so why say "be yourself???(in the sense of taking responsibility for everything you do...simple,no regrets)"(no pun intended)...spare me for I've blabbered on your space...and please please don't give a **** to what I say/said.Thank you

Nitisha said...

@Sandeep Kodam-
More than anything, your comments for whatever reason,intrigued me. Granted I didnt understand much of it, rather most of what you said, but there are a few things I'd like to say and ask.

1."I see that your consciousness of age has brought much complacency in your originality of thought."
What do you mean by that?

2.I chose that Neitzsche quote for a reason. It talked about originality, to break away from convention and do something new and not be party to the herd mentality. And I chose it irrespective of his somewhat Aristotle-esqe views on women.

3. I'm not sure one consciously rests his/her identity in the hands of others, unless it's due to some external force.

4.I don't like being called 'babe'.

5.You're allowed to write as you wish on my blog, and take up as much space, as long as it's not nonsense. :P

Nitisha said...

And Sankoobaba, simplicity is the key to most things in life, isn't it? :)
"Dont get lost trying to find meaning" has to be one of the most poetic simple statements I've heard in a long time! :)

sanket kambli said...

thanks..

but your comment that "i don't like being called 'babe'" reminded..
me of a quote from movie Barb wire..in which the lead heroine had this dialogue..where she says "Don't call me Babe" and kills the bad guy!! ha ha ha.

Srishti said...

Hmm, you know, even I wonder, since every person brings out different shades in you, how can you in the end remain YOU? How can you still claim to be the same person when what you're being is different in different groups? It just comes to you naturally, doesn't it?

Your post helped me understand this situation a little better- that ur basic ideology should be the same. Just the other day, I was discussing this with my friend and we came to a conclusion that although we may be different with different people, our core values in the end define us.

Nice post =)

Sandeep Kodam said...

k,re the first comment,it was my view of things and wasn't referring to you at all...(i never said it was conscious)
re 'babe',seriously,I'm sorry,and I admit it's a mistake.Is there anything else I could do now???
re Nietzsche,I'm a fan of his(if I've given u any impression that I'm anti-nietzsche),but more than that I'm concerned about u being directed towards fanaticism,as his opinions/works sometimes lead(k,this is what I believe),taking into consideration that u do a lot of reading.Sorry again and now I wouldn't be worried.
re complacency blah blah...
one,I didn't just take this 1 post r ur profile into consideration and two,when I said someth about u,there's someth else I c it in relation to(maybe it's too high)...and three,I wasnt judging u,I was suggesting someth...maybe to encourage you 2 think originally(since u read a lot,and there's possibility that u may imbibe others' opinions r take them for granted)
re blog space...
I'm the least interested in impressing others(gone way too far in my language,sorry for that).I should be respecting your personal space,sorry.
And lastly and most importantly,I want to say that my comments have come out of concern for you and not otherwise(I didn't want you to be taken away by pride,now that u've opined on a good topic)
Everything I said just now might, in myriad possibilities be false,but that's what I think is true,and I'm sorry for this...
oh,I just didnt want you 2 believe things blindly.see???that was what I wanted!!!how selfish of me!!!that's y I'm better off not giving any advice.
sorry and thank you...

Nitisha said...

For however misplaced it was, the advice meant something and one day I swear I will understand it and adequately reply to the above. Till then, thank you. :)

Hupendra said...

Nice comments.!! Oops.

Nitisha, now addressing to your thoughts, its true that we behave differently with different people. However to say that we wear multiple masks and move away from our natural self, to me, is not correct.

Our behaviors with different set of people, be it friends, parents, and others collectively makes us a person and forms our personality. Its not that each time you behave differently with your parents/sister. Its that you behave differently with different people. And that behaviour is goes consistent with them.

When you talk abt something which is related to your value saytem or principles then its true that, it must not change. It should be constant, no matter the situation.

Pallav said...

First off, lovely blog. Great layout. But most importantly some great thoughts. Doesn't seem to have come from a 17 year old.

What you talk about is the quest to find ourselves, understand who we really are, what makes us who we are, and all the questions related to it.

So about being a different self with different people, there are two aspects you need to considers - some people put on the act to be liked by the person they are with, some people adapt themselves so that they can be on the same plane as others. In the first case, you can say there is a lack of identity, but in the second case its just that you bring out that shade of you which suits the environment best - to be easily understood, or to better associate with people.

So it is all about your own identity - who you are and how comfortable you are being yourself. Most people dont know who they are and they become whatever the situation demands or suits them. But it takes knowing yourself completely to know which shade of you to bring out when with someone else. Its like this, your mom would be a different person when with you and when with her peers.

I don't know where but the meaning of life pops up somewhere. Well, can we even find a single meaning of life which applies to all? More still, can we find the meaning of life itself? I doubt it. All I know is that the only meaning of life that there is, is meaning you give to your life. As for more on this, you can always read "Man's search for Meaning" by Victor Frankl... I would highly recommend it for you...

And yeah, one last point. I was just putting my point of view, and trying to get a conversation started...