Sunday, August 8, 2010

A Tale of Two Aishas.

Aisha.
This beautiful name of Arabic origin means "alive", or "she who lives".

Two Aishas dominated the news this weekend, for two very different reasons.

Let's start with the trivial. The Sonam Kapoor-Abhay Deol starrer Aisha.
(First thoughts as I see this-BIMBOS!)
Why I even choose to write about this Bollywood chick flick is because it is supposedly an adaption of the Jane Austen classic, Emma.
And Emma, is one of the very few classics I can read and re-read forever, and then some.
Now, Bollywood(yes,I will call it that, calling it cinema is like calling fungi beautiful) churns out, at the very least 500 films a year. Is asking for one half-decent movie a year too much? That too, when the story you're drawing inspiration from has been around for the past 185 years. But I see the trailers and all I see is bright hair accessories and trendy shoes and silly dance moves.
This movie has got 2 stars out of 5. Who is surprised?

As a general thumb rule, I don't like watching movie adaptations of books. But tickets have already been booked for this evening by my parents.(I think.) Understandably, my expectations are zero.
I shall concentrate on my caramel popcorn and jumbo Coke in the worst case scenario that we actually do go. :P


Moving on now. To a way less glamorous Aisha.
Bibi Aisha, her name is.


The face on the cover of Time magazine is graceful, serene and unimaginably maimed. The heart-shaped hole where 18-year-old Aisha's nose should be is a mark of justice, Taliban style.





I'm pasting here the New York Times account of her horrific experience.

"At age 12, Aisha and her younger sister were given to the family of a Taliban fighter in Oruzgan Province under a tribal custom for settling disputes, known as “baad.” Aisha’s uncle had killed a relative of the groom to be, and according to the custom, to settle the blood debt her father gave the two girls to the victim’s family.
Once Aisha reached puberty, she was married to the Taliban fighter, but since he was in hiding most of the time, she and her sister were housed with the in-laws’ livestock and used as slaves, frequently beaten as punishment for their uncle’s crime.
Aisha fled the abuse, but her husband tracked her down in Kandahar a year ago, took her back to Oruzgan, and on a lonely mountainside cut off her nose and both ears and left her bleeding. She said she still did not remember how she managed to walk away to find help.
In Pashtun culture, a husband who has been shamed by his wife is said to have lost his nose, Ms. Naderi explained; from the husband’s point of view, he would have been punishing Aisha in kind."


I write this knowing fully well that Taliban-infested Afghanistan is home to a million more such Aishas. After all, 90% of the country's female population is banned from access to education, 97% women in the country show signs of severe depression and thousands are abducted, raped and killed indiscriminately. Reducing women to mere objects, the minister of education says, "It's like having a flower or a rose. You water it and keep it at home for yourself, to look at and smell it. It [a woman] is not supposed to be taken out of the house to be smelled." The plight of women, as stated by another Taliban leader, is that "there are only two places for Afghan women - in her husband's house, and in the graveyard."

From where does one even begin to comprehend the depth and and deep-rooted nature of extremism prevalent in the country? For heaven's sake, we are talking about a country's economy that is driven by its opium and hashish production and export.
And the U.S.A, for all its good intentions, must understand that unless the country decides to pull itself out of the medieval ages, no amount of war will change the sheer depravity of the mainstream figures in that country,be it terrorists, the government or civilians.

Bibi Aisha is travelling to the U.S. for reconstructive surgery this week. As the brave survivor puts it herself, “I don’t know if it will help other women or not, I just want to get my nose back.” 
This is the story of Aisha, eloquently, the girl who lives.


"It is a far, far better thing that I do, than I have ever done; it is a far, far better rest that I go to than I have ever known."
- Charles Dickens, last line from A Tale of Two Cities 

6 comments:

sanket kambli said...

well about movie aisha.. girl reviewer(asian age) gave it 4 star and a guy reviewer gave it 2(HT).. so its being termed as a chick flick..for me this in this sonam plays someone rich and beautiful, etc..which in reality her life..so till she plays something which is not herself..she is never going to win acting points from me..
and about afghan girl aisha..well what you said is the exact point..and I think US cant change afghan attitude or for that matter any extremist attitude..be it iraq or baluchistan.. the change has to come from within..
good post..and excellent contrast

Tangled up in blue... said...

You know, this is how I'm seeing these two girls this post is about..looking at the first makes me feel like I'm ensconced safely in India's large middle class and while I may never in my life possess even 10% of the money Sonam Kapoor or the stinking rich Delhi social butterfly she portrays, I'll be content with not letting international designer brands dictate my sense of self-worth or beauty or general mood for that matter.

As for the young Afghan girl (incredible how many of them make it to the iconic covers of American magazines, dont they?) she makes me thank, umm, the powers that be, I guess..that I was born in India, to the kind of family that doesnt have to hand me over to the Taliban and to a brute of a "husband" who'll think its normal to disfigure someone's face..

And this isnt the first time this brutal practice has been displayed in this manner in the Western media..there was a NatGeo channel (who else?) documentary about a 32 year old Pakistani woman, I forget her name, whose eyes were gouged out (the entire eyeballs, yes), nasal cartilage shaved off and ear pinnae cut off becoz she committed the grave crime of working in a factory and refused to allow her daughter to quit school and be married at the age of 13. She was being taken to England to have her face reconstructed so people wudnt be horrified to see her. But of course, her sight is gone.

See, Sonam Kapoor doesnt even need to make movies to proclaim how lucky she is. She just has to read about these women.

Btw, I quite liked the Aisha in Wake Up Sid. I guess I feel closest to her. These two Aishas seem to be at such opposite ends of life's spectrum, no? In every sense.

Tangled up in blue... said...

Wow, thats a really long comment..I guess I was typing as I was thinking..btw, love the C.D. quote! :)

Srishti said...

Hawww shit, Bibi Aisha :( Its just out there for us to see hun, such a HUGE difference between these two Aishas. Its so sad what happened to Bibi Aisha.

The Wake Up Sid Aisha was awesome, but Sonam Kapoor in I Hate Luv Storys was horrible! I don't like Sonam Kapoor, she just too...all over, too smiley. Daddy's-little-AmEx, not necessarily the most like-able person around.

Nitisha said...

The Wake Up Sid Aisha was pretty cool... I actually caught a bit of it on TV last night, after the horror of Aisha! :)

It's so sad how the torture and discrimination of women is a daily reality in countries like Pakistan and Afghanistan, that too, in this day and age. This,in the 21st century,when we talk of women poised to take on the world. To worsen matters, these maniacal men then justify their actions by quoting stats and verses from the Quran or Gita.

Sonam Kapoor was born with a silver spoon, and noone can(or should)deny her the right to enjoy her inherited riches. But to see her absolute crap performance in a rip-off movie inspite of all the money and goodwill riding on her, sure is a nagging source of irritation!

Dr Roshan Radhakrishnan said...

Just seeing that picture is horrible.. and I'm a guy ( doc ) used to seeing open skulls, ripped limbs et al...

Kudos on pointing out the "2 Aishas".. noone else, not even the papers, caught that..